An Awful Sunny Drive Back

by DShan on December 4, 2009

Post image for An Awful Sunny Drive Back

The first part of this post is here.

There’s something about a destination you’d rather not reach that makes it seem closer than you’d expected.

It was so damn sunny.

It was beautiful, really, and Illinois, if you don’t know it, is a very flat rolling state with lots of corn and long open roads.  The trip was about two hours and the turnoff was as close to a dirt road as road come without being made from dirt.

Hung a right onto gravel and everything looked familiar.  It’d been eighteen months.

A year and a half earlier I’d been in the same spot and driven home with this little thing of a puppy who I picked over his sister because he’d been so confident about climbing down a step.  He’d been the size of my forearm then. He barely fit in the passenger seat now.

Half a mile up was Vizsla Lane, where Linda and Jim raised supermodel dogs on a 200 acre farm.  I turned down the lane.

I idled…idled…the last mile into the compound.

The farm was Mother Nature’s sketchbook come alive; crows and rabbits and hawks and quail and dogs and chickens and people everywhere.  The state-of-the-art dog-run kennel housed fourteen pups.  The house dog, a mutt the size of a handbag, strolled the front yard wondering why all these other dogs looked the same.  There were golden Hungarian yippers everywhere and Branner was really just trying to keep his brain in his skull.

I’d called just two weeks prior.  The look on Linda’s face this morning reflected the excitement I’d heard when I called, asking if I might find Branner a new home.  Her reaction was overjoyed; she’d always wondered how he’d turned out, and his sister and mother were both wonderful, champion caliber dogs.  She told me that she unequivocally thought he’d be a treasure in the fields, and that their fields were a home for him indefinitely.

And here I was.  Fourteen days later.

There’s one way to remove a bandaid.

We all learn that.

My arrival was an event.  Everyone in every cage wanted to meet Branner, and he…well…imagine winning the lottery but they pay you with friends.  Best friends.

Jim asked me to stay, and he asked me to ride with him on the tractor as we took a three mile long loop around their fields.  He told me, “let him off that leash…he’s not gonna need it anymore“.

I responded, “um…we may never see him again”.

Jim’s quiet confidence painted a subtle smile; he grabbed the collar and snapped it off.

“That dog could make it to Wisconsin and still be able to smell us.  If he doesn’t come to you, it’s not because he doesn’t know where you are.”

We bumped and rolled out into a field the size of ten football fields covered in six foot stalks of corn and brush, and Branner went nothing short of apeshit.  I mean…he ran like he couldn’t believe himself.  He ran…no…he bounded through brush four times his height at full speed, almost looking down at his own legs and wondering if they could find another gear.

Every twenty minutes or so he’d pop out of the brush onto the tractor path and he’d stare me right in the eye and he’d thank me.  He was completely transformed.  It was the first time in his life that he’d had absolutely no boundary.

About an hour in, Branner came across our path and stabbed at a burrowing quail, sending it fluttering into the air for dear life.

Jim laughed.  “Of the fourteen dogs back there, only one found a quail on the first run.  And that was Branner’s sister.”

There’s something very unceremonious about giving up a dog.  You’re surround by people, usually, and in my case another fourteen dogs.  Back at the farmhouse, I gave a loving hug a few tries.  The connection between Bran and his mother a few feet away was palpable.  The distractions were intense.  I kissed him, and I kissed him.

And we put him into a beautiful indoor-outdoor kennel complex with his sister, where they ran side by side in circles feeling one another out.  They shared a bowl of water right in front of me.

I absently signed a piece of paper or two and I headed back out into the clean air, blue sky, and radiant sun.

My gut held tight, terrified of the idea that I might fully take in the loss I’d just put myself through.

It feels the same way right now, writing this.  I can barely breathe.

It was, in fact, the last time I saw Branner.

Update: It seems this post has upset a few people who have convictions about dog ownership, which I understand.  In writing this as a narrative I can see how it might sound a bit aloof with regards to the responsibility I took on when I got Branner.  Your opinions are warranted, but please understand you don’t have a whole lot of context for the decision I made.  If you look, you’ll notice that since the end of August I’ve written just ten posts aside from these two, not a one about my daily life.  You’ll get context, I promise, but you don’t have it right now.

In addition, if I really have upset you please tell me.  Don’t do so anonymously, I can take it.  You are more right than wrong.  Email me, if you’d rather not be negative here in the comments.

  • Sobbing for a complete stranger is something I do often, but not like this. Oy vey.

    We had a black and tan coon hound when I was a kid, like, seven. Nosey. She was the tiniest runt of a thing, and she grew to be bigger than any of her siblings. She was the smartest, prettiest, most energetic dog I've ever met. We spoiled her rotten, took her on walks everyday and regular trips to a friend's farm. We loved her beyond measure, and she was happy and healthy. None of that changed the fact that we had to give her up.

    We knew she'd have all the love and luxuries we'd given her, along with necessary things that we couldn't provide, like hunting and running amuk on acres and acres everyday. We knew she'd be happy with our friend, but none of that made it any easier.

    Through many updates, we learned that Nosey hunted and ran free to her heart's content, won dog shows left and right and slept in the bed until the day she died a very happy old dog.

    We did the right thing, as I'm sure you did. Love Love Love
  • Thanks for dropping by. That was a really nice story to read first thing
    this morning.

    I do know Branner's having a great time out in the fields, and in light of
    everything going on in my life, I made the right call.

    Happy New Year!
  • guest
    wow. i just stumbled on this post. unreal. like many, it made me cry. it made me cry because i know exactly how hard it is to give back a dog because i once had to do it. i had two and they did not get along and i could not take two dogs constantly fighting so i found him a home. i remember crying for days. i felt like the biggest failure but i couldn't do it. i looked at "bright" side in that i rescued both dog for anti cruelty and i gave the second dog to no kill breed rescue up in WI so I guess you could say I essentially found him a home.
    props for making the best choice you could. i know branner is happy with all his friends and the field.

    have you received any updates from him?
  • Court
    D - Hard thing to do. I know you struggled with the decision. I am gonna miss that wild thing. Would have love to seen him racing through the fields. I wish me had video of him walking your Mom ;-)
  • Wow I am so sorry. Clearly you didn't just decide to dump a responsibilit. otherwise why the drive and the kisses rather than an impersonal ad in the paper for the first taker. I hope to read more about what drove you to have to make that decision.
  • You did SUCH a good thing for Branner.

    Dave and I gave up a dog four years ago -- not something I'm proud of, but definitely a better decision for her. It's painful enough to manage privately, without having to answer to the harsh judgments of those who foolishly assume it's a light decision. Yes, some people irresponsibly get a dog and toss it away like it meant nothing, but you are clearly not one of those people. You were brave and unselfish. And when the timing is better, you'll be an amazing daddy once again.
  • Derek: I found your blog via a tweet, read through your blog post twice, read the comments... I'm a volunteer at a local humane society, a member of an anti-puppy mill organization, and a huge advocate for animals. Huge. When I hear words like "dogs" and "farm," I await the next sentence with baited breath because unfortunately these are too often negative and harmful environments for these animals; I hear firsthand stories and read about people giving up their animals because they can't care for them by taking them to shelters, letting them get lost and not attempting to find them (which happened to my parents' dog), or even much worse.

    I'm saying all of this because life leads us places that we never expect and sometimes we have to make a decision that's the best for our family -- yes, dogs included. And it's not easy. In fact, it's downright heart-breaking, but there's a right way and a wrong way to go about it.

    I'm so very relieved to hear that you made a responsible decision. And not just a responsible one, but one that seemed to have cared for the well-being of your friend. You've put the needs of the animal -- the one you're responsible for -- over the needs and desire for yourself, bringing him to a place that's also full of joy and family, a chance for that second chance. For that, I can't say much more than thank you. Good luck to Branner, and best of luck to you.
  • Man...
    This is the kind of post that makes social networking so powerful. That a perfect stranger can make this 26 year old cry.
    I may not know the whole story or the full context, but I do know that I have had many pets in my life and each one has touched my life in a different way. I also know I have seen people mistreat their pets in a way that is completely appalling because they are not willing to recognize their inability to care for the pet in the best way for that animal.
    This reminds me of a wonderful dog we had while we lived in Alaska. He was not meant for cold weather, but he thought he was and got frostbitten toes a number of times from gallivanting around with some local huskies. Before we moved to Alabama, we "set him free" on a farm in the Midwest with some friends who owned a farm. He ran so hard, so fast... and never looked back. And we didn't look back because we knew he was much happier to be free, away from the constraints of our human routine.
    I think giving him back to his family was beyond perfect... many people would have just given him to a shelter where he'd be exterminated or they would have left him on the street. You recoginized that the relationship could not continue, but you did your best to make it right. Not that you didn't already know all that, but I just wanted to reassure you that some strangers do not consider what you did (with or without context) to be selfish or wrong or upsetting.
    That's all... sorry to ramble.
  • I vividly remember this day. It was back before we met in person, when all we really knew for sure about each other was that our minds worked in fast, spiraling, and often identical ways. This day, this situation, this moment, is what made you so much more real for me. I remember your mood, your energy, the story, the context. You were sad in a way I had never seen from you before. Your raw emotion, how deep-in-your-core awful you felt about giving Branner back, I could taste it, and my heart broke for you.
  • Sigh. When I read the first part of this story, I almost knew this is how it would end.

    It may be true that I don't know a whole lot about you... but I know you loved that dog. I'm so sorry you had to make that decision. Must have been terribly difficult. It sounds like you did the right thing, though. That's the other thing I know about you-- you always do your best to do the right thing.
  • Swood024
    I love you D.
  • I love you too, S:) And your little baby boy, Jose.
  • justatitch
    Giving up a pet is a tough choice, but I think you deserve to be commended for not just abandoning him, but for finding him the best home possible. I know you will miss him, but I have no doubts that he is happily chasing quail. There is a big difference between letting the dog run the streets homeless and being responsible. Big hugs, though---must have been heart-wrenching.
  • Big hugs, right back atcha.
  • I understand why this post will upset people. As a volunteer for a local humane society that is overcrowded, in desperate need of a larger facility and the funds to help homeless animals, I get very angry when people give up their animals. To me, there just isn't a reason, its a lifelong commitment when you adopt, but sometimes it has to be done for the good of the animal.

    Luckily Branner had a breeder to go back to, most times these animals end up in shelters and when those shelters are overcrowded (which is always) animals must be euthanised. At the very least, in making your decision to give up Branner, you made sure he was taken care of and not doomed to be put down.

    I ask if you ever adopt again that you consider it a lifelong commitment and you consider a shelter animal rather than adopting from a breeder.
  • I wanted to thank you for such an honest, insightful comment. I do
    understand the frustration. I don't like what happened, but it wouldn't have
    happened if I'd felt as if I was becoming a major part of a broken system.
    I know I am part of it, and I'm hoping to bring context into why down the
    road.

    And without question, my next dog will be rescued.
  • You are a wonderful writer. Thank you for sharing.
  • So are you! Thank you!
  • ashley_TINTLIO
    Oh Derek, I'm so sorry you had to go through this. Like everyone else, I got a little teary. Its soo so hard giving up a pet but, despite not knowing context, it sounds like you made a good decision for him. My parents had to give away a very playful, very loving black lab when I was little because he just needed space to run and be himself and we couldn't give him that at the time. So instead he went to live on a farm, just like Branner and he was oh so happy and apparently never stopped running around all that land. Sometimes we have to do that, no matter how hard, in order to have the best for your dog and yourself. HUGS
  • Honestly. I think this is one of the most responsible things you could have done. I think too many dog owners have dogs for their own well-being rather than the animal's. You trusted your gut. You did what was right, in your opinion, and mine.
  • Thanks. I do subscribe to the notion that responsibility isn't something
    that's supposed to be convenient, and having heard the comment above and
    some other feedback, I think waiting to put it in perspective might have
    made this 'news' more contextual; lesson learned.

    I appreciate the support from everyone. It was tough, and I respect
    anyone's feeling on it. I didn't write this for validation, I wrote it
    because I wanted it out there.

    Especially because the people behind the screens are a big part of my life,
    and they kept asking me how Branner was doing:)
  • Derek, you just made me cry in public. And I can only imagine how tough this was for you, but given the context, I totally respect your decision and I know it's STILL gotta be tough for you. I'm glad I got a chance to meet and walk with that gorgeous dog. Now excuse me while I put myself back together before the other patrons here start looking at me funny.
  • That is exactly why I like writing; reactions. In public, even better!
  • :'(
  • I love this comment:)
  • Hugs.

    Just... hugs.
  • Big hugs back.
  • I just added this to the post, based on some feelings I woke up to this morning. I hope readers give me a chance to put all this in context, but more importantly feel like they are welcome to be honest here without hiding their identity. Really. I might have said the same thing Former Reader said, and I want to know who felt that way. I consider people who take five minutes to read my writing a priority...a friend of sorts. You don't have to agree with me or like me but please, please don't hide.

    Update: It seems this post has upset a few people who have convictions about dog ownership, which I understand. In writing this as a narrative I can see how it might sound a bit aloof with regards to the responsibility I took on when I got Branner. Your opinions are warranted, but please understand you don't have a whole lot of context for the decision I made. If you look, you'll notice that since the end of August I've written just ten posts aside from these two, not a one about my daily life. You'll get context, I promise, but you don't have it right now.

    In addition, if I really have upset you please tell me. Don't do so anonymously, I can take it. You are more right than wrong. Email me, if you'd rather not be negative here in the comments.
  • Oh D. I'm so sorry. I'm tearing up as I write this - it must have been such a hard decision between keeping him with you in Chicago or bringing him back to the farm. If I may ask, what ultimately made you decide?
  • It was hard. It's been hard. I didn't come to the decision lightly, and maybe the scariest thing was calling Linda and saying the words out loud. Making it a real possibility.

    It was the right decision, and I couldn't explain that all here in a comment, but I'm going to do my best to put it all in context soon. Sorry to be so 'to be continued' (queue the music).
  • There is a part of me that desperately wants a dog. Because every dog I've ever had was an incredible addition to my life. Then I think to myself "Sydney, you can't be selfish - NO dog would be happy here in the city - especially not the kind you'd want." I want a lab. Or a Golden. I want a BIG DOG, which doesn't translate AT ALL to city living.

    Was this hard? Of course it was. I can FEEL how hard it was just by reading this. Was it the best thing for Branner? You-fucking-betcha. To "Former Reader" above - grow up. Derek lives in CHICAGO and took Branner to PARADISE. Let's be serious - he did the right thing. He didn't discard of Branner, in fact, I think, he gave Branner a better life. One where he isn't cooped up in a Chicago apartment with no yard and nobody to play with.

    Beautifully written. Can we go play with puppies before we have #craftbeerchat on Monday? I need some dog time.

  • Former Reader
    Ronda down below said it better than I could have.

    There are plenty of dogs that are pretty darn happy in Chicago. I can guarantee that a dog with an involved owner that makes sure it is properly exercised and cared for is going to be a lot happier than a dog with a backyard and an owner that doesn't give two shits about it.

    What I take issue with is that, when somebody takes on the responsibility of a dog, it's a responsibility for the life of that animal. And if D really did have the dog "cooped up in a Chicago apartment with no yard and nobody to play with" as you said (and it's pretty clear that you're a buddy of his, so I'll take your word on it), then that's on D as a dog owner, because there are plenty of ways to remedy that. And it really just reinforces my point that he shouldn't be a dog owner in the future.
  • What you're saying's fair, as it relates to dog ownership. I stand by the
    fact that this particular story doesn't have context, and that's my fault. I
    honestly probably should have thought about it from the perspective of
    someone with conviction on the subject. I didn't.

    It has nothing to do with my place. Nothing to do with the yard. I think
    dog's love Chicago, and I'd raise a dog here.

    Branner was happy with me, and yeah, I do take solace in where he's at now.
    I wouldn't have followed through otherwise.

    Your insinuation that this piece had a single thing to do with blog traffic
    is misguided; I don't look at traffic. I haven't checked mine since
    January. If you look through my archives you'll find some stuff about the
    first blog I kept, and how giving a shit about traffic ruined writing for
    me. I just write. I do it in a narrative way. Writing about this (three
    months after it happened) was a lot more about my readiness to try and
    describe it than anything else.

    I hope that doesn't read an attack. I really appreciate that someone had
    the balls to be unpopularly honest. I mean that. I don't disagree with
    where you're coming from...and for reminding me that this piece of writing
    came out without any forethought as to its context I'm appreciative.

    I'm not saying context will change your mind. I'm just saying there is
    some, and it changed mine.
  • I coudn't tell you about what Derek's place is like, never been. I couldn't tell you what Branner's life was like, I don't live there. What I can tell you, and this is something that you should be able to deduce from being a "former reader" (indicating that you've read more than just this post), is that Derek is the kind of person that is passionate and gives 100% to whatever he does - be it work stuff, his career, relationships he has with people, etc. I know this from hanging out with him ONCE and from talking to him daily.

    Is this situation optimal? No - of course we'd all love to think that we live in a land full of pixie dust and unicorns where everything is magical at all times. I can attest that place doesn't exist - at least, not that I've found. The reality of the situation, no matter how you frame it is that the second that he realized he couldn't give this dog the life it deserved, HE SOUGHT OUT ONE THAT WAS A MILLION TIMES BETTER.

    I'll echo everyone in saying this sucks. It does. You think it sucks because you automatically assume that D's an asshole who can't take care of himself, let alone a pet and that he's irresponsible. Most everyone else here thinks it sucks because they actually know D and know that this was an incredibly difficult decision for him to make but in the end HE MADE THE RIGHT ONE. The dog is happy. He's romping around in fields and pastures with other pups and having a blast. How is that a bad thing?

    I think it's awesome that you feel so comfortable judging. Easy to do when you don't identify yourself, hmmm?
  • Puppy play time ain't a horrible idea, now is it. I'll try to put that on the docket. And here's to the day you get a big huge dog:)
  • Yeah, I got a little teary.
  • You don't cry, do you? :)
  • What? Uh, like every other day. For example, I don't remember the last time I saw a movie in theatres when I didn't cry. Watching at home= not so much, but something about the big screen makes me empathize with everything and everybody and I even cry during some parts of comedies.
  • Don't admit that in public! JUST KIDDING.
  • Former Reader
    I liked this blog up until this post. Please don't ever get another pet. They are a life-long commitment, not something to be discarded when they become inconvenient.
  • I updated my post with a 'response' to your conviction and reaction to my giving up the dog, which I respect and wish I knew who to attribute to. I hope you'll wait for some context to the whole thing, but what you read and invest in is your choice.

    I mean it, though, when I say I'd like to hear from you via email, because I don't think anonymously expressing opinions like this one provides any satisfaction. If it does, so be it. I am sorry to have upset you.
  • Former Reader
    Why? You don't know me. I'm just some random stranger that took a liking to your blog when someone re-tweeted one of your entries.

    Context is context, and your readers can only digest what you give them. If you choose not to give them the whole story, they can only judge you based on what you provide. If you want to tell some flowery, drawn out story, great. I don't think I would use a sad chapter in my life to drive blog traffic, but maybe that's something we'll never see eye to eye on.
  • Nuff said. That must have been so hard to write.
  • Derek, You just ripped my heart out!
  • Darby!! How ARE you? I'm sorry...this story's a bit intense, I know. There's more to it, but it needed to be written.

    Anyway, I can just drop over to your blog and see ridiculous love and cute little ones with paint all over themselves. I mean...how sad could you BE?

    Seriously, anyone reading this comment, go look at Darby's family. It's like the Happiest Most Beautiful Place Ever.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: